This is the eleventh installment in our It Happened On Manhunt series. Originally, we had only planned on posting the top ten stories as a way to celebrate Manhunt‘s tenth anniversary. But now? We’re having too much damn fun. The diversity of your tales has been remarkable… Falling in love! Making new friends! Learning life lessons! Threeways with NFL players!
With the exception of the last one, it’s kind of like a big gay Lifetime original movie, except with more hardcore gay sex scenes. And while we hate to sound so masturbational (at least in this particular instance), it just goes to show you that the Manhunt experience is entirely unique for each and every member. Why don’t you share your story?
Anyone who’s ever used the site has something notable that’s happened to them. Maybe it’s as simple as really good sex. Or perhaps you met your future (or current) husband? Either way, we want to hear about it! If you’re willing to indulge us, send an e-mail to daily@manhunt.net with the words “Best Manhunt Story” in the subject heading. We’ll return the favor by hooking you up with a FREE month of unlimited membership to Manhunt.
Now that we’ve gotten that out of the way, let’s move on to today’s exciting adventure! While the title of this post is pretty self-explanatory, you may or may not enjoy hearing all of the details. All in all? We couldn’t resist including it for this quote alone—“But when you think about it, how are you going to date a guy who let you fuck him wearing a maids outfit after he cleaned your room?” Yup. That happened.
– Dewitt
Photo credit: College Dudes
To read this member’s story, follow the JUMP:
This happened during my sophomore year of college. Over the summer, I had recently moved into the frat house and was sharing a room with one of the guys. That summer, all the guys living in the house got on a fitness craze, so we all were dieting and exercising… Helping me lose my freshman fifteen and then some!
Needless to say, I was getting more and more attention from men on Manhunt, which I wasn’t really used to. I would often use it to hook up with middle-aged men who were married or deep in the closet, because I wasn’t ready to step out with guys my own age. Personally, I didn’t think I had the looks for it, because I was overweight for most of my life. I had a little more to love. And guys my age were way too judgmental for me to handle.
It was in the middle of fall semester when it dawned onto me that I should start getting used to the attention. That summer, I’d lost about 35 pounds and began gaining muscle. Girls were checking me out regularly, and I mean the stuck-up sorority girls. So I contacted an old fuck buddy of mine to help me take new pictures.
I posted them online shortly after, and the responses were crazy. I was getting more ass than a toilet seat, but I was still in the closet. I still chose to fool around with guys in the closet who had more to lose than me.
It wasn’t until one drunken night I unlocked for a guy in town that was my age. He unlocked. I instantly knew who he was. He was the president of our rival fraternity, Jeremy. I was shocked. Not that he was gay—because he was always kind of feminine—but because of how dirty his photos were. I was a little turned on.
Luckily, he didn’t really recognize me, and we started chatting on IM. I got him to do some dirty things and send me some really naughty shots of him fingering himself, eating his own cum and begging like a dog. This dude was a freak! And I kind of liked this position I was finding myself in.
So he finally decided he wanted to meet and I agreed. I went to his dorm room (His fraternity didn’t have a house). He opened the door and quickly shut it in my face. He told me to go away. He felt betrayed since I didn’t tell him who I was or something like that. I told him to let me in, or I’d leak the photos he sent me. He let me in.
And we talked a bit. I got him to calm down and let him know that what happens in the room is strictly between me and him. He was hesitant. He had just gotten out of a relationship and said he “doesn’t do things like this normally.” I told him to relax and before we know it, we’re 69ing on his bed—him gobbling up my dick and me rimming his tight hole.
It was all ruined when he got a phone call from his ex. He answered, talked to him a bit and then hung up. He realized he wasn’t ready to fool around with another guy yet. I was pissed, but I respected his wishes and left.
It wasn’t until a few weeks later when were both at an Intra-Fraternity Council meeting that we hooked up again. Our moderator needed someone to work on the new bylaws and he volunteered. As everyone left, I stayed behind and talked him up a little. I got him to admit that he’s a submissive guy and liked when I tried to take control. Then I whipped out my phone and showed him the photos. He looked at me, and he knew what was up—my dick! Which I then whipped out and he began to go down on.
This would carry on for a whole year. It was like a game we’d play. He knew I’d never leak the pictures. And I knew he liked being a bitch. He loved doing awful submissive things, and I loved being in control. It was a role I never played out sexually until I met him. There is something erotic about having a guy just do anything for you.
He graduated that year, and I became the president of my chapter. A year later, right before summer I was voted MVG (Most Valuable Greek) at the Greek Picnic, which was open to all members including alumni, for all my philanthropy work and excellent GPA. I came out that day to everyone when I accepted the award. It turned out it wasn’t a big deal.
Also, turned out Jeremy was there. He came up to me, and we began to chat. I was expecting this to lead to us fucking in the woods or something, but he wanted to know if I’d be interested in a relationship.
I wasn’t, and I broke his heart that day. But when you think about it, how are you going to date a guy who let you fuck him wearing a maids outfit after he cleaned your room? I went off and drank with friends until I was drunk. Then I went to Jeremy and told him how much I wanted to rail him. And he turned me down. And that’s how it ended. But it was still a fun ride, and I owe it all to Manhunt.
should have dated him.
i hate guys who were fat, lose weight and become idiots too full of themselves.
ugh typically frat boy morons it’s guys like you why gay men like me don’t date anyone on campus simple because your asshole douche bags.
Jeremy will eventually learn to have higher standards, and to feel good about himself. He’ll look back on this skinny, girlish fag and ask himself why he even let himself be fucked by such a douche.
Hey hey hey, we aren’t all morons! But I admit, it is the norm.
Uh what the fuck?
This guy is a complete fuckwit.
Although I agree with every comment posted so far, I didn’t note anything that implied he had incredibly high standards. He saw that the dude was a president of a rival frat and went for the humiliation; it’s what frats do. Can’t blame him. It had nothing to do with his standards, in my opinion.
I agree, nothing about standards here. The poster was young, coming into his own and discovering gay sex without having to be ashamed. The fraternity president was in a different place – in the closet, private, but terribly wanting to act out. Of course, the poster didn’t want to be in a relationship. Sucks but you have to sow your oats before jumping into a committed relationship, otherwise you become the cheating douchebag. As pompous as the guy sounds, it is best he didn’t date the guy in the end.
ps. I don’t agree with the whole threatening to show the pictures just so he could talk to him. Douchebag move to “out” someone who is fearful.
I agree with all comments ( so far ) but N author defense he was honest enough about not wanting a relationship and he kept his promise about not releasing the photos something many of People ( perhaps some on this blog ) would have done . Insensitivity does not necessarily qualify as a DOUCHE !! BTW KUDOS 2 Jeremy for having courage for putting his heart ahead of sexual desires . ( something that many on this blog ) would NOT have done !!!
And, that’s one more reason why I would never join a fraternity, LOL
Pathetic !
damn got a hard on just by looking at his pics wooof wooo
BTW, those pics are not of the poster, just some random photos that Dewitt copped somewhere. Now, to get everybody pissed off for their “holier than thou” attitude!! If you were in a frat, young, hot, with hormones raging like all young guys , you know, even if you’re “above that now”, or so you want us to think, just how dick/ass crazy you actually were. Your were fucking horny and you would have gotten a piece of ass or given up some ass any way that you could get it or take it. Once again somebody was right up front with their actions and the hypocrites are once again coming out of the wormholes they inhabit! But then again, of course, if you were in a frat, weren’t good looking, hot, built, or horny, I guess you can be forgiving for carping about this guy being honest, but just barely!
Holy self-absorbed-former-fat-fuck-fraternity-douchebag Batman!
He was walking a thin-line, but those last 3 paragraphs just did him in! LOL
P.S. no one is arguing young’uns don’t have hormonal rages… I think the kicker for most of us has to be turning Jeremy down for a relationship, getting drunk and having the gall to try to bang him again–all within a few hours!
the guy in the pics is really hot!
it doesn’t matter if you are or where a hot and horny looking men the fact that he did something to make some one look like a piece of meat is disgusting yes I understand the whole wanting and fucking around who hasn’t done that we are only human but the fact that he used this whole idea on that guy that he is gonna out me out to the whole world is wrong. it the reason when people like this who have done things like that have made more young men go off and eventually kill themselves because they feel ashamed and are probably not ready to deal with the emotional side of there own sexual identity. And Don’t tell me that not all frats members and I use the word frat cause I know how much I bugs you when people use the term frat cause regardless if this was A another guy you use the same tactics on woman and that doesn’t set you apart from the rest of you FRAT! how dare you not consider that the least bit moronic. that whole we have to tear you apart in order to build you up to our standards crock went out the window ages ago and the fact that many of your so called philanthropic and so called brotherhood organization follow such cruel things is wrong and you wonder why people choose to stereotype fraternities.
calm down, it’s fake
Great story…blah blah blah…the dude in the pics is sooooooo freaking adorable and sexy. More of him please!
you’ve really pulled back the curtain
No words
Um. Why the fuck can’t you date a guy who let you fuck him wearing a maid outfit after he cleaned your room?
Que hermoso hombre de donde eres baby…Good very..very good me baby you and from pelsse.me swete.. kiss,.Dany..
I’ve never paid for a gay video, but after seeing David Knoll above, I bought my first video. Love seeing that guy bust a nut.