It's pretty much a given that Casey James will be going home tonight on American Idol, so this is probably our last opportunity for an Idol-themed round of Who Would You Rather. We never got the impression that Casey had much appeal with the man-on-man crowd, but we still can't stop ourselves from asking… Between him and Lee DeWyze, who would you rather?
As we move towards the finale, we'd also love to hear your thoughts on this season! Do you think Crystal Bowersox is a shoo-in for the win? Or could DeWyze turn out to be a worthy competitor? On another note, is there any chance that Casey will make it to the final two?
– Dewitt
To cast your vote, follow the JUMP:
im all about lee, so look out kris allen, you got some serious competition here…now if you could only score some shirtless pics dewitt!
Lee hands down.
After next season they should go back to the drawing board and come up with another show. People are tired of the same old six and seven and it’s showing in the failed ratings
There were rumors earlier this season that Casey is gay. Some guy was claiming to be his ex-boyf. VFTW had the story but it didn’t grab much attention.
Lee for the who would you rather, but Crystal for the WIN! She’s awesome
Casey for me, please – he’s straight up sexy. But he’ll be going home tonight for sure. I want Crystal to win, but I’m prejudiced – I live in Toledo, Ohio and the bar she mentions playing is my favorite haunt. Based on last night’s performances though I’m worried for her. I will say that Simon picked a way better song for Lee than Ellen did for Crystal (not that it was bad, but Simon’s pick was just better) – I won’t go there with the song picked for Casey, poor guy never had a chance.
Don’t be so sure. Casey has made it well past his expiration date. He is hot and the girls like him. I won’t be totally shocked if he knocks Crystal out. It would be wrong but not surprising.
I do like Crystal a lot though. I think she is amazing. And I kinda think she has a thing for Lee.
I would have a one nighter with Casey but Lee would be my BF. Anyways Casey is going home for sure tonight.
Wardrobe does a pretty good job of disguising Lee’s chubby shapeless body lately… but going back a while and looking at him in his ill-fitting jeans… flabby flat butt… I’d say I have to go with Casey who has a much better body. Both have cute enough faces, but from the neck down… and naked I’m thinking there’s a big difference that we are not seeing!
DeWyse… but I could change him for Tim Urban in a second!
Casey is adorable but I am certain the Lee will win it all! 🙂
TIM URBAN! ha
ok, LEE of these two
how about a threesome…
Casey is certainly the most sexy, but not nearly as talented as Lee and Crystal. I really think that Crystal outshines the other two and has a great chance of winning. Casey would be tops on my “Who would you rather” list, but if Lee lost a few pounds, I might change my mind!
Definitely Casey. That way he could just be eye candy and I could fill his mouth with something else before he ever tries to sing.
Casey is sexy as hell, and he can sing. However, he is not as talented as Lee or Crystal! The women and girl voters is was kept him in the competition. For sure he is going home tonight. If, he doesn’t people are not voting for what actually counts,which is the SINGING! I would have a one night stand with Casey, however I would have a relationship with Lee. I love his humbleness and shyness…Those are great qualities to have! And, I also think he is very SEXY as well!
of these two, Casey. If you had made it for all the guys in the final 10 it would have been Tim, Aaron, then Casey in order of hotness.
agree with despisestheskank, neither of these two, but Tim….in a heartbeat…..
I am sorry Lee looks too much like Danny Go”off”key and has a big melon head. Casey looks good in jeans so he gets my vote.
“‘Whom’ would you rather?” is actually correct! 🙂
i want Lee as my boyfriend he’s a total hottie. would love too see him shirtless. Tim Urban was the hottest guy on the show for sure.
lee? just because you grow hair on your second chin, doesn’t mean it’s not there.
I stopped watching after Siobhan got the boot. I’ve sworn off Idol hah!
oh and neither. Casey is too pretty and Lee.. hate that deer in the headlights look he’s always got on his face.
Lee, but Mike also
Idea to Dewitt:
Who would you rather?
Gerald Butler or Russell Crowe?
I think Lee is ugly and I can’t stand his voice…=/