Who Would You Rather?: Hawaii Five-0 Edition

In case you didn’t notice, the fall television season kicked off within the past couple of weeks. Among the various network line-ups, we have a show entitled Hawaii Five-0, which has been described as a “re-imagining” of the popular series from 1968-1980. Although we’d normally say this remake’s doomed for failure, it may have a chance thanks to its hunky male cast members.

Alex O’Loughlin has taken over the role of Detective Steve McGarrett, while Scott Caan will be filling the shoes of Danny “Danno” Williams. Since they’re both incredibly attractive men, you can probably guess what question we’re going to ask next… Who would you rather?

UPDATE: Funny story! We didn’t actually watch the premiere (or do any basic research for that matter), so we had absolutely no clue that Daniel Dae Kim was even on this show. To make up for this “travesty”, we’ll be placing this week’s winner against him in the next round!

– Dewitt

To cast your vote, follow the JUMP:


32 thoughts on “Who Would You Rather?: Hawaii Five-0 Edition

  1. Agree that (a) Daniel Dae Kim should have been included and (b) there should have been a “why do I have to choose” option.

  2. Scott Caan, for sure……you can see on the show he has the personality to go with the hot face and bod. Then the next night, Alex, then the next night, Daniel….rinse, repeat….

  3. They can both tag team me anytime. I liked the opening show, and the shots of Oahu were also beautiful, and it made me home sick for Maui, where I lived for 5 years.

  4. Not that I want to start another one of those flare-ups that happens on The Ten rather regularly, but Daniel Dae Kim’s omission is really sad. I mean, Kim is probably one of the best known actor in the cast. (Yes, I know Scott Caan is James Caan’s son and he’s on Entourage and the Ocean films and all that. Alex O’Loughlin was in Moonlight, then what? Another rom-com roadkill with J-Lo.) The fact that he got overlooked just make the constant assertion that “manhunt daily is not ‘white oriented'” sounds rather hollow. I am not looking for a minority quota or insanities like that, but c’mon, all three of them roll out at the opening credit, and I failed to see the reason Kim should be dropped.

  5. I’ve lusted Alex since I first saw him in his vampire role, Moonlight. But I could handle the two of them together.

  6. Scott def. He reminds me of his dad so much.
    That scene where he sneaks upstairs for a lustful quickie in “The Godfather”. So hot!

  7. @ B1, I have to agree with you on that one. All three men are attractive from top to bottom so why focus on only two of the stars? This is a raunchy gay-male site, isn’t it? Or is is it just catering to a specific crowd. Now I know manhunt wouldn’t do that!

  8. another vote for Daniel Dae Kim — the few times they allowed him to take his shirt off on Lost were relevatory; the man is SMOKIN’ hot, and not including him is an absolute travesty.

    To make up for it, you should announce that Alex vs Scott is just the preliminary, and that the winner has to go up against DDK! 🙂

  9. @B1 Thanks for your keen observation and for asserting a viewpoint that clearly is missing here.

    Yeesh.

  10. BOTH, Please!! …and Daniel Dae Kim, also. Sure, I’d be busy. I have no doubt all four of us would be very, very spent!

  11. I’ve wanted to FUCK (or be fucked) by Scott Caan since I saw The Boiler Room’s deleted scenes where’s fucking some chick on a bed. Soo hot.

  12. If you had bothered to watch the premiere…. They’ve already had their first spat and are in the process of falling madly in love with each other. They spend way too much time stealing glances at each other. I predict their first KISS by ep.3!

  13. i’m kinda surprised the vote is so close, altho, scott caan IS fucking hot. dig how short he is, u know he’s got an amazing bubble butt. but i voted for the austrailan.

  14. i don’t suppose it would really matter, though, if dewitt did actually throw daniel dae into the mix, with the other two..

    ..the majority of the viewership of this blog has long made it clear, that it’s eurocentric in its preferences.

    so, danny would not have had even a chance, against his theoretic competition, anyway.

    that said, this is not a judgment on scott (for whom i, personally, ´d voted) or alex — it’s a judgment on the viewership.

  15. fortunately, i don’t have a “religion” to make me feel any qualms for judging what i see (and don’t see).

    additionally, whoever came up with that judge not lest ye be judged “adage” should have been hanged, for eventually corrupting the minds of billions.

    and, certainly, if I am not above getting judged, then others shall be subject to the same.

    🙂

    (it’s only fair.)

  16. I personally think Scott Caan looked better about 12 years ago, when he did Varsity Blues (wasn’t there a shot of his bare ass in that movie?), but that’s just me

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.